• Contact
I’m generally immune to internet memes, not sure why, but it makes sense given the hardy ethnic stock in question. Rooting around in bogs for millenia combined with even infrequent ancestral consumption of haggis necessarily renders a hardy constitution, which naturally spills over into other facets of one’s life, like the intergoogle. I have watched Rick Astley a couple of times, but that was in concert, so it doesn’t count. Yesterday Cricketslayer made me watch this one out of sheer intimidation from his handle, and for some reason it struck me, and not solely for the Lou Holtz angry slobberfest. Slobbangry. Slangry. If I was on the set I would totally start using that. “Dude, don’t say that – seriously, your going to get Lou all slangry.” Try it with a drawl. Slangry.
Anyway, that’s not the point. If Florida fans dream about Lou leaning over them while they sleep and softly slispering tebow… tebow… into a puddle in their ear and wake up screaming that isn’t my problem. I can’t fix the world. But there is a bigger issue here that needs to be addressed, something that needs to be said, and I’m afraid we’re the only legitimate news outlet that has the journalistic integrity to do it.
Why is everyone comparing Colt and Tim in the first place?
Whew. That felt good. It’s not even that they run completely different offenses in different conferences. I’m cool with that. My real issue, and more importantly, is why we have to choose sides? That doesn’t really seem fair. What about those of us who like both? I mean really like them, in that I think Colt McCoy is the avatar of St. Paul and Lee Majors and I like Tim Tebow almost as much as scally does, which is even more than I like Colt. Transitively it’s a tie. This is absolutely gut wrenching, and it has to stop. Remember Rick and A.J.? They were totally different, and fought all the time, yet also cool and solved crimes together. Why can’t it be like that?

Colt can be whichever one is cooler, so maybe Tim (Rick) has the mustache. But that guy kicked ass, which would be Colt, so that doesn’t really work. So Tim can be A.J., who was really smart and polished. Wait. I guess I hadn’t really thought this through. This is messing with my head.
In any event, if we’re going to be forced to choose between them we shouldn’t we at least pick our own criteria, stuff we believe in, stuff that matters? Half of the arguments I’ve seen involved nothing but useless stats, which only tell part of the story, the field part. Falls a little short, doesn’t it? Misses the big picture entirely. I pasted some from the NCAA stats site to prove to you how inscrutable they are. Who’s the better passer… who’s the better rusher…. who’s to say? colt for both Shut up. I’m trying to make a point. It’s more than winning percentages. Come on people. Is that all you really care about?
Passing Efficiency
Rank Player Pos Cl Gm Patt Pcomp Comppct Int Intpct Pyds Ydspatt TDs TDpct Rating
4- Colt McCoy, Texas- QB JR 6 165 131 79.39 3 1.82 1557 9.44 17 10.30 189.0
17 Tim Tebow, Florida QB JR 6 149 093 62.42 1. 0.67 1235 8.29 10 6.710 152.8
Total Offense
Rank Player Pos Cl Gm Rushes Gain Loss Net Patt Pyds Plays Totyds Ydspl Yds/gm
9- Colt McCoy, Texas- QB JR 6 59 405 57 348 165 1557 224 1905 8.50 317.5
42 Tim Tebow, Florida QB JR 6 73 263 84 179 149 1235 222 1414 6.37 235.7
See, I bet you can’t even read that. I made it and I can’t. It’s unselfinscrutable. Which is a word I made up, in case Lou reads this, and someone is there to catch it on tape. Just kidding Lou. I like you, I wouldn’t keep you up ’til 1 am and give you antihistamines known to cause paradoxical agitation in the elderly like ESPN did. I’m your friend. Say unselfinscrutable just once. Say it.
In any event it doesn’t seem so clear now does it, statswise. In lieu of an actual formatting table for stats, here are the real categories- the QB qualities that actually matter.
1. Guttiness
2. Clutchosity
3. Smile
4. Aroma
5. Powers of Christianity
Scipio made me put the last one in.
1. Guttiness
McCoy drinks a gallon of milk every day.
ADVANTAGE- McCoy.
A gallon of milk? Actual milk. WTF, man? I mean I like it, but I’m not trying to support the entire Wisconsin dairy industry. You realize just about everyone on earth is at least a little lactose intolerant, right? Since McCoy’s intestines are actually under assault, probably as we speak, I’m going to have to give him the guttiness edge.
2. Clutchosity
Tebow’s girlfriend has big ones.

Another meme I seem to lack immunity to, and with all due respect to Colt, and knowing full well how intense the Oklahoma pass rush is, I can’t even imagine the game it’d take to walk up on that. Even as the quarterback at Florida, that’s daunting. If he said ten words before blurting out boobies! the guy is clutch.
3. Smile

h/t to Deadspin for the Tebow pic, but this one’s too close to call. I don’t usually look at dudes. And the Gladiatory costume kinda freaks me out. See I mispelled Gladiatory. That’s from being freaked out. Anyway, HenryJames and CrazyJoe have a side debate on this one which might be the swing vote. So to speak.
4. Aroma
Colt hails from the clean and breezy steppes of north/west Texas, and his ears smell like sunshine.
ADVANTAGE- Colt.
5. Powers of Christianity
Tim’s dad was a minister. Legacy.
ADVANTAGE- Tebow.
Wow that was harder than I thought. At least we cleared some things up. I feel like we made some real progress today. Tomorrow we’ll tackle the SEC vs Eisenhower’s post war staff decisions- subcategory, Is Mark Richt’s offense more futile than the Morgenthau Plan?
Scipio Tex said:
October 14th, 2008 at 9:52 am
Thank you for adding powers of Christianity to your criteria. I’ve gotten in trouble before asking interview candidates that question, but I think it’s valid. I slide them a notecard and say, “List me your powers.” If the powers are pagan, so be it. But I want SOME powers of some variety.
Given that Colt has led 7 4th quarter comebacks for victory and Tebow none, I think it’s fairly clear who has The Glow.
steven said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:13 am
The contest is sort of like a modern rendition of the old David vs. Goliath theme and, with regard to this particular contest, I would say that the more things change, the more things stay the same. I would take Colt to sling a clay pellet smack between Tebow’s eyes.
Aside from that imagery, in the football category, I would say that Colt is clearly better than Tebow. Florida would be a better team with McCoy under center rather than Tebow, although the Gators might look a bit less Philistine. Possibly alot of the struggles of the Gators may actually be due to shoddy play at the QB position.
Now, I don’t know Tebow in personal or anything and I have never spoken to him in person, but I gotta a suspicion that one of the problems this white but foreign born prototype of a college QB has is that he may not be all that up above the shoulders. In other words, I am saying that he may just be dumb as a rock or a dinosaur or a dodo bird or, maybe, a male underwear model. I mean look at that f*cking smile of his. Am I the only one who sees stupid written all over and behind that All-American smirk of his? I mean has anyone ever met someone with a “I am dumb” smile like that who did not meet expectations and actually turned out to be not stupid?
Hippie Killer said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:26 am
I’d give Tebow the Heisman for 4 straight years based on his girlfriend alone.
Jables said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:29 am
Comparing quarterbacks without mentioning championships? Tebow has an SEC and national title… Colt played very well in the Holiday Bowl last year.
Bob in Houston said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:29 am
A legacy? From Harrisburg??
8straight said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:36 am
Lou deserves all the grief he gets but, man, his crew did him no favors. That was like a Mike Wallace 60 minutes ‘hat cam’ ambush. You think maybe someone on that set enjoyed old Lou hanging in the wind?
Mr. Know it All said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:37 am
That was funny as hell
Parlin Hall said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:38 am
Hippie Killer is right about two things.
Big Tex said:
October 14th, 2008 at 10:50 am
“Tebow has an SEC and national title”
Yeah, kind of like how Matt Nordgren has a Big 12 and national title.
RomaVicta said:
October 14th, 2008 at 11:20 am
Tebow does have the described stupid smile. I can see him with eyes squinted and surrounded by deep red as he tries to suppress a guffaw in the aisle of an airliner after accidentally farting into the face of an old lady sitting in an aisle seat. I see that red-eyed, red-browed, near-exploding face for the duration of the flight as he trembles mirthfully in his seat. “Funniest thing ever. And I seen Jeff Foxwordy on the TV!”
Further, I have to ask, wouldn’t such an event indicate that just maybe you’ve overrated his powers of Christianity? Surely Colt, in the same situation, could lay hands on the cloud and maketh the odor diminish.
Bill Nye said:
October 14th, 2008 at 11:46 am
Colt is obviously genetically superior since he can digest that much cow teat juice with no consequences besides a winning smile and gleaming hair.
Colt wins. It is SCIENCE!
Mack Brown said:
October 14th, 2008 at 11:48 am
nice fun bags
steven said:
October 14th, 2008 at 12:21 pm
Comparing quarterbacks without mentioning championships? Tebow has an SEC and national title… Colt played very well in the Holiday Bowl last year.
Yea, the above is an avoidable plus in Goliath’s corner, but then it’s not like he did that alone without a good supporting cast or carried his team on his back to victory in the MNC games like VY did in the Rose Bowl. On the other side of the coin, at the present moment, if Colt can look so all world with the set of overachieving skill players he has now, just imagine how much he could light it up with the speed of light skill players Tebow has surrounding him – think about that. When you consider the blazing f*cking speed surrounding stone age man, it does sort of make you wonder if it is not Tebow’s cave man level of intelligence which is holding the Gator’s back on occasion. I mean, what else could it be? The man is built like a football god, so the other plausible althernative and guess would be that the man is dumb as shat.
And also, yea, I’ve got to give credit where credit is due. I gotta admit, I figure I’d also have such a stupid smirk on my face too if I was so lucky enough to be standing next to a set of boobies like that and, even more so, if I was as tall as him, so that I could look down her shirt while she was not looking. But then I’ve also heard that those wa wa boobies might just belong to his sister, and so, if that is the case, then I guess I would have to take a little bit of that credit back. Sister or no sister, it’s hard to fault any man for smiling like a goofyball when in a vicinity of a pair of boobies like that. I mean, I’ve never had a sister, but if I did, I wouldn’t be cursing God and losing my faith, if she turned out to end up with a pair of overflowing melons like Tebow’s sis.
Oh by way, since Tebow is always going off on a mission, could it be that Tebow is really a Mormon on the low down. I could see why some folks would want to keep that on low down. Maybe that pic is just one of those everyday, normal, run of the mill, cozy Mormon family pics of a normal, run of the mill Mormon family get together and gathering.
Hippie Killer said:
October 14th, 2008 at 1:32 pm
Colt kind of looks like Luke Skywalker in that picture.
If that is Tebow’s Sister, well then shi-eut! I’d lock his parents in a room and tell them not to come out until they reproduce enough daughters for every Longhorn Fan in Texas.
p said:
October 14th, 2008 at 1:33 pm
“Comparing quarterbacks without mentioning championships? Tebow has an SEC and national title… Colt played very well in the Holiday Bowl last year.”
Tebow threw 1 pass for 1 yard….lol
He was more a running back in those days, rushing 10 times for 39 yards. Chris Leak was the Qaut-A-Back for that game. Since he has been “the man” he has gone 14-5. In that same time Colt is 16-3.
steven said:
October 14th, 2008 at 2:07 pm
You know, now that I think about, I would be smiling like a full blown dumbshat too, if I was Mormon and had a sister with overflowing melons like that. Who wouldn’t be? Maybe this secret is out and this is why Utah is said to be one of the fastest growing states in the Union. Also, they say that Utah has one of the lowest rates of depression, heart disease, other general health issues, and suicides. Just maybe all these good happenings have one thing in common: cute sisters with big overflowing melons. I know if I was a prof., I would love to get a grant and due a factfinding, multi-year study on the matter. Hell, along the way, who knows, I might just find a cure for cancer.
Sasha_Is_A_Longhorn_Dog said:
October 14th, 2008 at 4:22 pm
In regards to their smiles: dude, they are both HOT. I mean, I’m 26 and typically won’t date a guy who is more than a year younger than I am, but man. Those two? I’d rob the cradle.
Spawn of Cthulhu said:
October 14th, 2008 at 4:25 pm
Did you hear about the happy Roman?
He was gladiator.
Scipio Tex said:
October 14th, 2008 at 5:07 pm
You’re 162 in dog years.
Scipio Tex said:
October 14th, 2008 at 7:54 pm
Scipio Tex said:
October 14th, 2008 at 7:55 pm
McCoy – game, set, match.
PESCKYCOW said:
October 20th, 2008 at 10:37 am
Stop ogling her “Yahoos” or she’ll wipe your face with the floor. I was testing your will power, which, apparently, none of you have seemed to master. Leave her tits alone!
PESCKYCOW said:
October 20th, 2008 at 10:49 am
BTW, only 5 percent of the country is utilised. Much of North America is uninhabitable. That being said, your bound to run into someone in The Northeast who has family or knows someone in either The Midwest. South, or West. The number of Canadians alone with relatives south of the border is… I don’t know. But in any case, Jamie Moyer being from Souderton, just a coincidence.
PESCKYCOW said:
October 20th, 2008 at 10:58 am
I’m just trying to prove to you I’m human. None of you seem to believe…
BLINK 183/PC said:
October 20th, 2008 at 11:45 am
That’s because humans don’t have any restraint or any kind of self-control. They see a beautiful woman and like Mountain Lions they go in for the kill. Which brings me back to sports. Manning went in for the kill, yesterday. It was ALL his doing. Now if Zarell retires because of his knee, at least he is retiring while still on top. I just hope he doesn’t tarnish his image by becoming one of those “celebrities”…please don’t!
BLINK 183/PC said:
October 20th, 2008 at 12:30 pm
Actually, I was just being sarcastic. I don’t care what he does, quite honestly. Its his life, afterall. As for The Phillies. Even if they come in as no.2, pretty impressive, eh? Now you’ll all be subjected to that lo-tempo disco song.
BLINK 183/PC said:
October 20th, 2008 at 1:57 pm
Ah yes…Demon Zarell. Anyhow, yes, yes I know LVIA is the only International Airport between Newark/NYC and Pittsburgh. Good thing, I hate to travel to the airport esp. when I want to check out some college football action.
BLINK 183/PC said:
October 20th, 2008 at 2:23 pm
Yeh, that’s because personal letters, highly personal letters were shared with the world. Why? Trust no one.
ANONYMOUS said:
October 20th, 2008 at 3:28 pm
I can understand your frustration because you want people to level with you and noone seems to muster up enough courage to really level with you. One can only imagine what it must be like to be you. I wouldn’t take it so personal, though. People behave that way when confronting something totally new and unexpected. Dry your tears, hang in there. I’m going to pray for you, brother. I am going to shower you with prayer and peace. That is all I know when confronting something such as this. You confront unknown/evil with love and peace.
sct said:
October 20th, 2008 at 3:39 pm
Ask Blink 182 and others 4 forgiveness…no sympathy 4 the devil…
PESCKYCOW said:
October 20th, 2008 at 4:26 pm
Well, I already know what most people think, anyway-and it isn’t pretty, trust me on that one.
fbomb said:
October 21st, 2008 at 9:32 am
I have no idea what y’all are talkin’ about, but this story sure was funny.
I think Colt just moved back into the lead tho – the interwebs say it ain’t really his GFF
http://mbd.scout.com/mb.aspx?s=188&f=1657&t=1603050
Plus Colt has the most coolest name for a Quarterback anyway…
ANONYMOUS ONE said:
October 21st, 2008 at 1:55 pm
Perfect. That’s how we keep IT in the “underworld”.
Vasherized said:
October 21st, 2008 at 2:10 pm
I hate the word ‘meme’ more than steven likes glory holes at Oil Can’s but Doperbo’s comparisons are legit.
It’s McCoy in an apostolic landslide. Tebow can have the moral motorboat victory.
Sasha_Is_A_Longhorn_Dog said:
October 21st, 2008 at 5:07 pm
Chase Daniel seems to like some aspects of McCoy.
PESCKYCOW said:
October 22nd, 2008 at 10:32 am
I like keeping certain aspects of my life “in the closet”. I’m also a Coservative who would like ALL 3 Presidential contenders as President. Tough choice because I like all 3!!! I see what others don’t, maybe. I come from a family of die-hard Labour supporters. My parents-Conservative/3 out of 4 of my sisters are Liberal.
Scoobydue said:
October 22nd, 2008 at 10:54 am
Scipio and that Pesky Doperbo are the dynamic duo of College Sports blogs.Are they evil Pagan check mates? Kinda like rabies-you don’t usually die of rabies and then recover. However, you can have organ failure as a direct result and be brought back for a 2nd chance, DR. THAT’S NOT UNHEARD OF. I guess you have 2 first names to distinguish you from all of those other so-called “kings”. Plus its a Jewish name and a Christian name, that’s why there are so many kings. Esp. the Jewish ppl all hold their sons’ balls and think their little dragons are kings. Then they get them into the media-so all I hear are David in the media.
DRP said:
October 22nd, 2008 at 11:05 am
My sister has 2 first names, too! But in Europe family they just call me Dmitar. My parents came up with 2 names for me from that name. They wanted to name me Dmitar but it was considered “too Slavic”. I’m complicated by virtue of the moon and stars. Au revoir!
DRP said:
October 22nd, 2008 at 11:42 am
Hope that explains all of your questions. Thank you for the snail mail. Now if you will all just let me exist. I know this one motel in particular was popular for the terminally ill. The hospital was right there and they would send all of their no hope patients to the motel to die. They were dying to check in-they never checked out. That being said, as an unemployed part-time motel clerk, I feel I am highly qualified to give a little career advice to Mountain Lions Eli-on and Peyt(li)on Manning- keep giving it all you’ve got! No matter what! Its all your doing. No one else. But your skeptical because of the BTW/Green Manning phenom (boy witch coming of age).
DRP said:
October 22nd, 2008 at 11:45 am
Cullen that evil Nurse who used to murder patients worked at that hospital.
Jew Yorker said:
October 22nd, 2008 at 1:02 pm
Life is learning how to effectively assimilate. You sir couldn’t assimilate if your life depended on it. Yes, NYC suburbs are spilling onto The Lehigh Valley’s doorstep-so there, pescky! Where’s Jemima Shawnette? F8cking Eli & Peyton I bet! You even said so yourself that Eli & Peyton wanna fuck Aunt Jemima! Like Shoshanna-the big lady ambushed in The Gulf War in 2003.
DRP said:
October 22nd, 2008 at 1:32 pm
NYC has more “talent” because they have more people.
SnodumOpportinitu said:
October 25th, 2008 at 6:15 pm
The work done here surpasses that of the 1945 Yalta summit.