Connect with your Facebook Account

• Contact

Football Articles

1

The History of College Football Recruiting Cheating- Part 3

Posted by TaylorTRoom on June 6th, 2008 under Football, Recruiting

When we left off, college football recruiting was relatively violation-free, because there really weren’t any rules to violate. More precisely, conferences set their own rules (I assume independents did as well). Ivy League schools favored no athletic scholarships and no special jobs for players. Big 10 and PCC (precursor of the PAC-10) schools had no scholarships, but would provide jobs, with limits on pay.

SEC and SWC schools had athletic scholarships, jobs for players, and all were funded by the boosters. Athletes that were eligible for the GI Bill stood to make out even better- per a 1966 Sports Illustrated article by Bear Bryant, GIs returning from the war were still given the money for tuition and living, despite the GI Bill also paying for that.

The northern schools were really dismayed by this situation. In the immediate post-war period, many of the players they lost to the military were returning to finish college at other schools, down south. They found that they could not recruit new players when they had to compete with schools that were more generous in their benefits. The schools in the Ivy League, the Big 10, and the PCC had better reputations academically, but that was not enough to overcome the cash on the barrel head that the southern schools offered potential players, many of whom had no intention of pursuing careers outside their home states.

The thing to note here is that each school or conference is espousing a vision of college football recruiting that puts themselves at an advantage. If, as the Ivy League proposed, there were absolutely no benefits for football players, and they were drawn from a pool of students that would all be enrolled anyway, the Ivy League schools would be formidable recruiters. If college football were limited to 1250 SAT types from middle class and up families (paying their own way), the Ivy League schools would definitely out-recruit Oklahoma or Alabama.

The Big 10 and PCC schools, with academic reps not as good (although still very good), needed to offer a little more, and that’s what they proposed. The southern schools, less established and in poorer regions, were ready to recruit players from a talent pool that included all economic and academic strata, and they were willing to pay what it took to get all of those recruits signed up. If there were no limits on recruiting, they would get all of the players they wanted.

This is the fundamental point to keep in mind when viewing cheating in recruiting- when you limit inducements to defined packages, the offers from different schools vary in value. The value of a degree is higher at some schools than others, the cost of tuition varies, and some locations are more sought after than others. Extra inducements can be seen as a way to equalize the value of the different schools’ offers.

Of course, the trouble was that some athletes were good enough to create bidding wars, and with no rules there were no limits on the bids. A 1952 Time magazine article notes that one halfback was offered tuition, books, room, board, $300 per month spending money (equivalent to $2K/month now), and $5K upon graduation.

So, in 1948, the northern schools found themselves at a recruiting disadvantage to the southern schools. How could they address that, given that regional conferences set standards, without stooping to the southern schools’ level? The answer was to have the NCAA, to then a relatively powerless body as far as regulation went, assume a role as national regulator of recruiting. In the 1948 NCAA convention, the “Sanity Code” was instituted. This instituted a policy that no athletic scholarships were allowed, but off-season jobs were allowed, as long as the pay was limited to NCAA standards.

Then, a curious thing happened. Seven schools, on a follow-up questionnaire, noted that they were continuing to offer scholarships.

The issue of these schools, dubbed the “Sinful Seven” (Virginia, Maryland, V.M.I., V.P.I., The Citadel, Boston College and Villanova) was brought to the 1952 NCAA convention (per the rules at the time, the convention addressed violations, not the current committee). In a 130 – 60 vote, the NCAA decided to not punish them. At that point, the “Sanity Code” was dead.

A year with no NCAA rules (or at least no NCAA enforcement) ensued.

During this time, schools had to do a lot of soul-searching about what they could live with, and how badly they wanted to participate at the highest level of football. Remember- the era of televised games was beginning and schools didn’t yet know what that meant (the money and exposure was nice, but would it hurt the take at the gate?). The NCAA reconvened, and ruled that schools could offer athletic scholarships.

The PCC tried to forgo offering scholarships, but had an ugly scandal immediately when it was discovered boosters were paying players on the side. The Ivy League decided to step back from D-1A, and not offer athletic scholarships or jobs (then, as now, the Ivies still offered preferred admissions consideration for prospective players, which definitely has a value). Almost immediately, teams from this once-powerful conference started getting pummeled by teams like William and Mary. By 1968, it was noteworthy for this league (which as recently as 1948 had players like Chuck Bednarik) to have a player, Calvin Hill, talented enough to be a NFL prospect.

So now there were rules. Next, we’ll look at cheaters.

Article Tags:

, , ,

More from this Barker


Share This

  • StumbleUpon

One Response

  1. dedfischer said:

    June 7th, 2008 at 6:08 am

    I am really enjoying this series, TaylorT. Very excellent work.

Leave a Reply

Follow Us

Related Articles

Hot Forum Topics

Activity

  • bigdukesix commented on the blog post Bush Paves the Way for Henderson?   23 minutes ago

    Kiffin’s father is a great coach, but the rest of that staff isn’t. Orgeron and Kiffin are both good, dirty recruiters and mediocre to poor gameday coaches.

    How important is that in college football? How good of a gameday coach is Mack Brown? Greg Davis?

    Orgeron is actually a damn fine defensive line coach,

  • Tim commented on the blog post NIT Preview – Seton Hall   28 minutes ago

    How much longer to football season?

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Patrick Bateman commented on the blog post Bush Paves the Way for Henderson?   49 minutes ago

    CTJ,

    Always impassioned. I agree with you that his delay had to do with not being eligible to sign rather than awaiting for the smoke to settle. However, the point is not with motive but with opportunity. Maybe the kid and his family don’t know anything and just trudged along with his planned

  • CloseToJumping commented on the blog post Beat the Barkers NCAA Tourney Bracket   1 hour, 41 minutes ago

    I am angling for the weekend with SizzleChest. I am hoping to channel his evil in the right directions.

  • Casey Heathcott commented on the blog post Want to plant my feet on Rampart Street…   1 hour, 49 minutes ago

    Interesting read by a Kentucky writer: Apparently Kansas and Baylor are the only two teams with a shot at winning it all. http://www.courier-journal.com/article/20100316/COLUMNISTS01/303160023

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Mister Mike commented on the blog post State of the Union – NU Basketball, Part 1 (or Why We Are Where We Are)   2 hours, 8 minutes ago

    I get what you’re saying, but honestly, it’s a cop out. Period. If the AD was to actually commit some resources into building a program, we would be competitive and probably would even give K-State a run for its money. We may never be a KU, but we sure as hell wouldn’t

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • J Rog commented on the blog post Bienvenidos a Miami: Heat Preview   2 hours, 56 minutes ago

    Totally agree re: RJ. I’m hesitant to shout it from the mountain tops until he does it against a contending team. So far his success has been against 2nd tier teams.

    Ginobili is just incredible to watch right now. Just goes to show how hurt he really must have been last season.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Sancho wrote a new blog post: 2010 Football Schedule Released   3 hours ago

    09/05/10 at Texas Tech

    09/11/10 vs. UAB * Ford Stadium

    09/18/10 vs. Washington State Ford Stadium

    09/24/10 vs. TCU Ford Stadium

    10/02/10 at Rice * Houston, Texas

    10/09/10 vs. Tulsa * Ford Stadium

    10/16/10 at Navy Annapolis, Md.

    10/23/10 vs. Houston * Ford Stadium

    10/30/10 at Tulane * New Orleans, La.

    11/06/10 at UTEP * El Paso, Texas

    11/20/10 vs. Marshall * Ford Stadium

    11/27/10

  • James commented on the blog post Things To Do While Not Watching OU in the NCAA Tourney   3 hours, 15 minutes ago

    Nate, agreed on the buying players. What does the NCAA do? Oh yeah, you “vacate wins”. I vacated my bowels this morning.

    I was busting your balls on Oklahoma. I have had some good times in some of the surprisingly scenic areas. Also, Maker’s is my poison and who would ever

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Burnt Orange Wookiee commented on the blog post Bienvenidos a Miami: Heat Preview   3 hours, 18 minutes ago

    The emergence of RJ being what we thought he would be seems pretty big. Oh, and that Ginobili guy is playing pretty good right now. Seeing Manu be Manu always brings a smile to my face.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Blake Stansbery wrote a new blog post: Arkansas Razorback Football’s Top Six Impact Freshman for 2010   3 hours, 45 minutes ago

    The Arkansas Razorbacks’ 2010 signing class did a good job of filling areas of need and adding size, speed, and talent to Bobby Petrino’s roster.

    The major recruiting services did not rank the Hogs among the top 25 recruiting classes, while the Max Emfinger and Tom Lemmings of the recruiting world did think more highly

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Ibas water bottle commented on the blog post All Signs Point to March Madness Expanding to 96 Teams   3 hours, 47 minutes ago

    Somewhere in rehab Sean Sutton is pissed this didn’t happen 4 years ago.

  • Kevin Berger wrote a new blog post: Bracket Analysis: The Beasts of the East   4 hours, 5 minutes ago

    If the South is a region of guards, the East is a region of men. Large men, that play an old school, physical brand of basketball. Guys like Demarcus Cousins, Kevin Jones, Damion James, Trevor Booker, and Al-Farouq Aminu, put the power in power forward.

    These guys rebound above the rim and

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • J Rog wrote a new blog post: Reggie Miller is a Bad Man   4 hours, 25 minutes ago

     

    If you haven’t yet, I highly recommend watching ESPN’s latest 30 for 30: Winning Time about the Indiana Pacer’sReggie Miller’s rivalry with the New York Knicks in the early 90’s.  Anyone that can make Spike Lee look stupid is a friend of mine.

    The things that Reggie did to John Starks in those playoff series are

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Nordberg commented on the blog post Texas finishes sweep of Iowa   4 hours, 43 minutes ago

    Green and then Workman I’d imagine.

  • J Rog wrote a new blog post: Bienvenidos a Miami: Heat Preview   4 hours, 50 minutes ago

    If we can score, we have a chance.  The Heat are a poor team in a mediocre conference this year and don’t come with a lot of fire power.  The one thing they can do is play defense, holding teams to 95.2 points per game, 5th best in the NBA.  Dorrell Wright returns from a

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Nate Heupel commented on the blog post Things To Do While Not Watching OU in the NCAA Tourney   4 hours, 57 minutes ago

    coloradoag:

    First of all, I’ve very seriously thought your proposal #9 over. See: Calipari, John. People don’t seem to care if you buy basketball players. Only if you do it blatantly (USC) or you call/text them too much.

    Oklahoma (outside of Oklahoma City and Tulsa metropolitan areas) is a lot of fun if you’re

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Sailor Ripley commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The South is a Bear of a Bracket   4 hours, 58 minutes ago

    Ha ha ha ha! It’s Joel Osteen’s world. You just live in it.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • admin commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The South is a Bear of a Bracket   4 hours, 58 minutes ago

    Ha ha ha ha! It’s Joel Osteen’s world. You just livesin in it.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • admin commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The South is a Bear of a Bracket   4 hours, 58 minutes ago

    Ha ha ha ha! It’s Joel Osteen’s world. You just live sin in it.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • ghostofagroundgame commented on the blog post Beat the Barkers NCAA Tourney Bracket   5 hours, 6 minutes ago

    I will own that tote bag. And it will hold my porn.

  • James commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The South is a Bear of a Bracket   5 hours, 21 minutes ago

    Baylor has the horses to make it to Indy, but Scott Drew is the Mike Gundy of college hoops. He’ll find a way to blow it.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • HenryJames commented on the blog post Robinson can, no?   5 hours, 56 minutes ago

    Yes, it sounds like he is planning on hitting Texeira third.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Kevin Berger commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The South is a Bear of a Bracket   6 hours, 8 minutes ago

    “And I can understand the Longhorn fan thinking mighty Baylor goes all the way. After they bitch slapped the Horns three times this year, they are the basketball equivilent of the three foot long rat my wife saw in the garage.”

    I actually like Baylor based on how they played Kansas and to an extent KSU.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Ag_in_TX commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The South is a Bear of a Bracket   6 hours, 15 minutes ago

    Of course not.

    Here is another bold claim – all 7 Big XII teams bolt out the gate and win their first round games.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Kevin Berger commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The Wild West Regional   6 hours, 21 minutes ago

    Work, I love Xavier. Really athletic team that feeds off of mismatches that superstar guard Jordan Crawford creates. Hell, he’s good enough to carry X past Minnesota and even Pitt if he’s hot.

    The problem for XU is that they don’t defend as well as they have in the past. They’ll have

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Kevin Berger commented on the blog post Bracket Analysis: The South is a Bear of a Bracket   6 hours, 35 minutes ago

    Ag, cool, I agree with pretty much everything you say except your claim that you dictated tempo to UNM. But no biggie.

    The reason I like Siena is that it’s basically the same team that beat Ohio State in the tourney last year and then played a 1 seeded Louisville team down to the wire.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Mister Mike wrote a new blog post: State of the Union – NU Basketball, Part 1 (or Why We Are Where We Are)   6 hours, 36 minutes ago

    NU’s Ugly Duckling Program

    Read that and you’ll say to yourself “State of the Union of…what??”

    I know that’s what most of you will say. It’s not really shock or surprise that NU has a basketball program, though. It’s that sense of shock and surprise to anyone (especially our Barking Brethren over at OBK) that

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Hiphopopotamus commented on the blog post We talkin’ ’bout brackets   6 hours, 47 minutes ago

    I’ll say the same thing I did at March to March…

    I love this Baylor team. They’ve got all the pieces for a run and they’re in a ridiculously underwhlemingly regional, BUT…

    It’s Baylor. They haven’t won a tournament GAME since I think 1950…now we’re expecting them to go out and win 4 in a row?

    Certainly those

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Hiphopopotamus commented on the blog post We talkin’ ’bout brackets   6 hours, 47 minutes ago

    I’ll say the same thing I did at March to March…

    I love this Baylor team. They’ve got all the pieces for a run and they’re in a ridiculously underwhlemingly regional, BUT…

    It’s Baylor. They haven’t won a tournament GAME since I think 1950…now we’re expecting them to go out and win 4 in a row?

    Certainly those

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });